The Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology at Saint Barnabas Medical Center

Publications

 Winter 2006

REALISTIC EXPECTATIONS FOR THE INFERTILE PATIENT IN THE 21ST CENTURY

MARGARET GRAF GARRISI, M.D.
Director of Assisted Reproductive Medicine,
The Institute for Reproductive Medicine and Science at Saint Barnabas

Key aspects of modern infertility treatment include: ovulation induction (OI), in vitro fertilization (IVF), intracytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI) for treatment of severe sperm factor infertility; and sometimes includes special procedures such as micro-epididymal sperm extraction (MESA), testicular sperm extraction (TESE), and single sperm freezing (SSF). In addition to reviewing these treatment areas, I will also discuss Pre-implantation Genetic Diagnosis (PGD) as a treatment for recurrent pregnancy loss; the impact of maternal aging and the importance of day 3 FSH levels; and exciting developments in cryopreservation of embryos as well as eggs.

Ovulation Induction (OI):
Approximately 30 percent of infertility arises from ovulatory dysfunction. Eggs live in cysts in the ovaries called follicles, and the only thing that ripens the egg inside the follicle is Follicle Stimulating Hormone (FSH). There are only two places to get FSH: from the pituitary gland in the brain, or a medication out of a box.

There are two medications that stimulate FSH production by the pituitary:

  • Clomiphene citrate (Clomid® and Serophene®) causes the pituitary to increase production of FSH. Anti-estrogen side effects of clomiphene citrate (in about 20 percent of women) include thickening cervical mucous, which may make it more difficult for sperm to penetrate, as well as decreasing the thickness of the endometrium and decreasing the chances of implantation.

  • It is hoped that the newer medication, Letrozole, will decrease the side effects of clomiphene citrate while giving the same safety, ovulation and pregnancy rates. With these oral medications there is an 80 percent chance of ovulation, a 5 to 15 percent pregnancy rate per cycle, and a very low multiple birth rate of only 5 percent, mostly twins.

  • If these medications are not successful, ovulation induction with FSH medications, such as Gonal F, Follistim or Menopur, can be used. These medications have a higher rate of ovulation and pregnancy, but they are injections, and more expensive, and have a 20 percent multiple birth rate. Women with polycystic ovarian disease (PCO) may also be treated with medications to decrease their insulin levels, such as Metformin, which may also aid in induction of ovulation.

In Vitro Fertilization (IVF):
IVF continues to be the superior treatment for female infertility due to tubal disease. It is frequently more efficient than surgical intervention, since pregnancy rates have increased so greatly during the 1990s. Improvements have been made in embryo culture systems, which has led to increased selection of “hardier” embryos, like blastocysts, for implantation and higher pregnancy rates, as well as decreasing multiple birth rates.

Intracytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI):
ICSI has revolutionized the treatment of sperm factor infertility. Even those men with no sperm in ejaculated semen can be helped if there are sperm in the testes, which can be attained by such surgical procedures as MESA (aspirating sperm from the epididymis in the testis) or TESE (removing sperm from a testis biopsy). Prior to these techniques, donor sperm may have been needed.

Single Sperm Freezing (SSF) is a technique that is only available at the Institute for Reproductive Science and Medicine (IRMS) at Saint Barnabas. SSF allows the TESE to be performed many weeks before an actual ICSI cycle. This allows a couple to know that sperm will be available for the ICSI cycle before the wife starts cycle medications, so they do not need donor sperm available for back-up use.

Pre-implantation Genetic Diagnosis (PGD):
PGD continues to aid in increasing the live birth rates in IVF by decreasing miscarriages due to chromosomal abnormalities of the fetus, some of which increase with advancing maternal age. PGD for gene problems, such as cystic fibrosis or sickle disease, has been possible for many years but not widely used due to the technical difficulties of false positives and negatives. These techniques are improving greatly and we will begin to see a much greater use of PGD for genetic diagnosis of specific gene disorders.

Maternal Age and FSH (follicle stimulating hormone) levels:
The importance and impact of maternal age on fertility is not new, but if I had a single take home message in this article to impart, it is that maternal age is still one of the most important factors affecting the treatment outcomes with any infertility treatment. The younger the potential mother, the higher the pregnancy rates with IUI, IVF, medications or surgery. In any individual situation, “it is what it is;” women cannot change their situations or certainly not make themselves any younger. However, if there are prospective choices regarding a relationship and/ or having children, I advise women with a choice to choose parenting sooner rather than later. The unfair female biological clock is real, no matter how young a woman feels, or how good she is about weight, exercise or sun block. FSH levels on day 3 of the menstrual cycle may give information about ovarian reserve and the likelihood of responding to FSH medications. “It is essential for women to plan where they want to be at 45 and work backward, armed with the knowledge that the window for having children is narrower than they have been led to believe, and once it begins to swing shut, science can do little to pry it open.” (TIME, 4/15/2002)

Cryopreservation:
Cryopreservation of embryos has been performed successfully for many years. What will be coming into the forefront in this millennium will be the successful freeze-thawing of oocytes (eggs) with improved pregnancy rates. There are thousands of babies born from freeze-thawed embryos but only a few hundred from frozen eggs. This is because good techniques were developed first for embryo freezing, and pregnancy success has been better to date with frozen-thawed embryos than eggs. However, there is certainly a need for improved egg freezing techniques for women without a partner who do not want to use a sperm donor to make embryos, but would rather freeze their eggs for later use. The most obvious candidates are single women with cancer who may be rendered infertile by their treatment. Another group is younger women who have no partner presently but want to cryopreserve their eggs for a future pregnancy when they find a partner but are older and less fertile. Ovum donation would also be more accessible and affordable if ovum donor banks could be started with cryopreserved eggs.

The Importance of Early Treatment
Approximately 20 percent of couples who are of childbearing age are infertile. Sadly, only about 50 percent of these people seek treatment. Of this group, about 25 percent seek treatment from their general ob-gyn physician and never see a fertility specialist. At a time when there are so many options for successfully having a child, most of these couples never complete testing or receive appropriate treatments. My second “take home message” (after the first, which is starting to get pregnant younger), is to see a reproductive endocrinologist earlier for testing and treatment. Don’t waste precious months or years with incomplete testing or ineffective therapies.

The Institute for Reproductive Medicine and Science of Saint Barnabas is recognized internationally and maintains pregnancy rates that are among the highest in the world and treats patients from 43 states and 17 foreign countries.

If you are interested in an appointment, please contact the IRMS at (973) 322-8286 or visit the website at www.sbivf.com.

[ top ] [ back to index ]


Obstetrics and Gynecology MENU


Find a Physician